How much collectivism can a country bear?

OECD countries ranked by spending limit: the highest government spending, in % of GDP, a country can carry before its growth after borrowing drops.

OECD countries ranked by spending limit

Measured limits come from a clear drop in growth after borrowing. Estimated limits come from the indicator below.

The indicator behind the estimated limits

The line is fitted to the 10 countries with a clear drop in growth after borrowing. Each country's distance from the OECD average sets its position on the chart.

How each limit is calculated

  • Measured limit: how far the country's spending stood from the OECD average around its clear drop in growth after borrowing, added to the 2024 OECD average of 42.5%.
  • Estimated limit: the same calculation, with the gap from the OECD average taken from the country's quality of life and the line in the chart.
  • Margin: the range that likely holds the true limit 90% of the time.
  • Quality of life: the OECD Better Life Index figure, multiplied by 100.
  • GDP growth: average yearly growth in real GDP per person, 2023 to 2025. Inflation is removed.
  • New borrowing: the state's average yearly deficit, 2023 to 2025, in % of GDP. "None" means a surplus.
  • Growth after borrowing: GDP growth minus new borrowing.
  • Public debt: total state debt in 2024, in % of GDP.

What to doubt

  • The margins are about 15 to 21 points, so most estimated limits are too rough to say if a country is over or under.
  • Countries over their limit average -2.4% growth after borrowing, against -1.7% for countries under it. The correlation is -0.33.
  • Growth after borrowing is the harshest reading. It assumes every borrowed euro counted fully as income that year, which may overstate the effect.
  • The indicator rests on only 10 countries, and those countries do not sit tightly on the line.
  • The indicator assumes quality of life sets the limit, so it cannot prove that idea.
  • Quality of life depends partly on the economy and on state spending.
  • The limits assume the weight of the state caused each growth drop. Other shocks fit some dates, such as the 2008 financial crisis for Spain, Latvia and Estonia.
  • Competition from outside the OECD, such as Dubai, is not included.
  • Ireland's GDP is inflated by multinational companies, which makes Ireland's spending look too low.

Sources